Who Gives A Crap sells two tree-free toilet paper lines, and picking between them is the real decision — not whether the brand as a whole deserves an eco label. The recycled line reuses paper that already exists. The bamboo line grows a fast-renewing plant instead of cutting a tree. Both skip virgin forest pulp, both ship plastic-free, and as of the current U.S. product pages (checked August 2026) both are now made to the same 3-ply thickness, so the old “recycled is thinner, bamboo is plusher” shorthand no longer holds. What’s left is a smaller set of real differences worth knowing before you pick a box.
Affiliate disclosure: this page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, The Zero Waste List may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Recycled or bamboo: what’s different
Who Gives A Crap’s 100% Recycled Toilet Paper ships as “mega length” rolls, 385 sheets each, sized 3.97 by 3.97 inches, made from 100% recycled paper and listed as comfy 3-ply. The Premium 100% Bamboo line ships as “mega length” rolls too, sized 3.94 by 3.94 inches, made from what the company describes as sustainably sourced 100% bamboo fiber, and listed as extra-cushy 3-ply. Both product pages say plastic free directly on the listing, and both say the rolls work with most septic systems. That’s a closer match than the brand’s older marketing suggested — the meaningful gap now is raw material, not comfort tier, and “extra-cushy” versus “comfy” reads more like product-naming than a verified softness difference this article can confirm.
Recycled paper is the lower-footprint option on paper alone: it reuses fiber that’s already been produced, cleaned, and processed once, rather than growing and harvesting a new raw material. Bamboo still avoids the slow-growing trees behind conventional toilet paper — WGAC’s own site puts the industry-wide toll at a million trees a day — but growing, treating, and shipping bamboo fiber is a heavier process than reprocessing paper that already exists. Recycled is the more conservative default; bamboo is the upgrade for someone who won’t switch to recycled at all, not a straight improvement over it.
Pricing splits the two lines further apart than the packaging suggests. As of August 2026, a 24-roll box of recycled runs $42 (about $1.75 a roll) and a 48-roll box runs $68 (about $1.42 a roll); bamboo’s smallest box is 12 rolls at $28 (about $2.33 a roll), stepping down to roughly $1.56 a roll at 48 rolls. Bamboo costs more per roll at every box size checked, which is worth knowing before assuming the softer-sounding option is a wash financially. Compare current listings and other tree-free brands in our recycled toilet paper guide.
The recycled-versus-bamboo tradeoff isn’t unique to toilet paper: our bamboo paper towels guide checks the same fiber question for paper towels, plus when a washable cloth replaces the roll outright.
Packaging and certification
Both lines list their roll wrap as plastic-free on their current product pages; Who Gives A Crap’s own copy frames the paper wrap as the alternative to plastic packaging, not a decorative extra. The company holds Forest Stewardship Council certification (license FSC® C190271, verified on WGAC’s own site) and is a Certified B Corporation, meaning it has been independently assessed by B Lab against a standard set of environmental and social governance criteria rather than self-declaring the label. Those two marks cover forestry sourcing and overall business practice; neither one is specific to a single roll of toilet paper, so treat them as company-level context rather than proof about the box in front of you.
Limited editions and holiday wrappers
A few times a year Who Gives A Crap sells a limited edition: the premium bamboo roll in new wrapper artwork. In 2026 that meant the Parks Edition with Parks Project over the summer, the Spooky Edition for Halloween and the holiday Gift Edition. Each was sold as WGAC’s premium 100% bamboo roll at the same box price as the standard line, so an edition changes the wrapper, not the roll. Buy one when you are restocking anyway.
The wrappers are where an edition can earn a second use. WGAC says its roll wrappers are recyclable paper printed with vegetable dyes; we have not seen that tested independently. It also pitches the holiday designs as gift wrap, and wrapping presents in them before buying new paper is the lower-waste move. When they do go out, check that your local program takes printed paper, because WGAC’s recyclable label does not settle that.
The current edition, launched Oct. 28, 2026, is the Gift Edition: seven holiday designs at $75 for 48 rolls or $49 for 24, with no end date given. Buy the Gift Edition at Who Gives A Crap. The Parks Edition has ended; our Parks Edition page covers what it was.
The donation model, and what it doesn’t cover
Who Gives A Crap states, on its own site as of August 2026, that it donates 50% of profits to water, sanitation, and hygiene programs through partner organizations. That’s a real, structural commitment — profit-based giving at that share is unusual for a consumer products company — and it’s the company’s own reported figure rather than an independently audited one. The company doesn’t currently publish a cumulative dollar total on its site.
The donation model is a reason to prefer this brand over a comparably priced tree-free competitor with no giving program. It isn’t evidence about which of the two rolls has the smaller footprint — that’s a separate question, decided by the material and shipping trade-offs above, not by how the company spends its profit.
The shipping question
Who Gives A Crap currently advertises free shipping with verified carbon offsets on U.S. orders over $25, its stated way of addressing the transport footprint of importing paper and bamboo products. Offsetting is a mitigation, not a reduction — the shipment still happens — and this article did not find a current, specific breakdown of where each roll is manufactured to weigh transport distance more precisely. Buying a larger box less often cuts the number of individual shipments, which is the more direct lever a shopper controls.
Which to buy
Default to recycled if the goal is the lowest-footprint roll and the softness difference doesn’t bother you: same plastic-free wrap, same septic compatibility, lower per-roll cost, and a raw material that’s already been produced once rather than freshly grown. Choose bamboo if you’re switching a household off a plush conventional brand and a change in feel is what will actually make the swap stick — a bamboo roll that gets used beats a recycled roll that gets returned to store-brand tissue. Both product pages say the rolls work with most septic systems; if that’s a specific concern for your system, our septic-safety breakdown covers what “septic-safe” actually means for dissolvable paper.
For the bamboo roll against its competitors, the bamboo toilet paper comparison puts Who Gives A Crap beside Save Trees, Reel, PlantPaper, Betterway, Bumboo and Cheeky Panda on sheets per roll, cost per 100 sheets, FSC license code and PFAS disclosure.
For the rest of a plastic-lighter bathroom, our non-toxic shower curtain liner guide checks PVC, PEVA, and EVA options the same way this review checks paper.
Check current Who Gives A Crap prices and box sizes →
Sources behind the material claims
- Who Gives A Crap, 100% Recycled Toilet Paper and Premium 100% Bamboo Toilet Paper product pages, specs and pricing checked August 2026.
- Who Gives A Crap, About Us and Our Global Impact pages: FSC certification, B Corp status, and 50%-of-profits donation claim, checked August 2026.
- Forest Stewardship Council, certificate FSC® C190271.